Reflections/Jonathan Gramling
Election Reflections
As the smoke cleared after the November 5th election, Donald Trump was declared the winner of a decisive victory having received 312 Electoral Votes with 270 needed to win. Trump won about 58 percent of the Electoral College, yet he won only 50.2 percent of the popular vote. That’s hardly decisive. He just squeaked through in terms of any perceived mandate. Why the 8 percent difference between the Electoral College and the Popular Vote? It’s because the Electoral College is skewed towards rural, Republican states. Republicans get more representation in the Electoral College than they would in the popular vote.
Trump’s election is hardly a mandate. But I also have a lot of other questions about this election.
First, why did 6,816,888 fewer people vote for the Republican and Democratic candidates? While Trump gained 1.6 million votes over his 2020 total, Kamala Harris did 8.4 million less that Biden did in 2020. There could be a number of reasons for this happening.
First, the 2024 campaigns totally focused on the seven swing states, the so-called purple states. It seemed that Trump, Vance, Harris and Walz and their surrogates were coming through Wisconsin almost by the hour. And it was being reported that a similar track record was being kept in the other six swing states. Well, that leaves 43 states almost entirely neglected in this presidential race unless they also had a crucial Senate seat or ballot question on the line. How does this project to the average voter that their vote doesn’t count if they live in one of these 43 states? How does this suppress the vote? How would this change if it was the popular vote — your vote and mine — that decided the presidential vote instead of the 538 individuals gathering in their state capitols casting votes that will be transmitted to the vice president and Congress on January 6th? What difference would it make if each candidate had to compete in all 50 states plus Washington, D.C.? What would happen if everyone’s vote were enfranchised instead of written of because it really doesn’t land in the seven states up for competition?
Where did the 8.4 million Democratic votes go? Right up to Election Day, there was a tremedous amount of chatter on social media that the 2024 election was rigged against Trump. And then, all of a sudden, when it appeared that Trump would win the Electoral College, the election-rigging chatter died down to almost a whisper. If this were millions of everyday Americans expressing their belief that the 2020 election was stolen and that the 2024 election was rigged, how could the chatter end so relatively abruptly? For better or worse, Americans are individualists and I can’t imagine that their chatter would stop at the same time. Ain’t no one going to tell them when and what to do. But it all died down almost at once like an orchestrated effort.
Did the Russian influencers and bots stop immediately from orders from Putin because they didn’t want to have people start raising questions that Trump’s victory was fixed and a fraud? It just feels so orchestrated. If it were individuals doing it — knowing individualistic Americans like I do — it would have gradually fallen off after many hours or days.
And speaking about Vladimir Putin, what did he and Trump talk about during those seven private phone calls after Trump left office? Were they talking about the weather in Moscow that time of year or who their favorite NFL team was? Back in the old days, this would have been called treason for a private citizen to be talking with a foreign head of state that was on the other side of a conflict, this time in the Ukraine. But as I said in a previous column, Trump has Rich White Man Privilege Immunity. He can violate the law seven days a week and twice on Sunday. He can shoot someone on Seventh Avenue in New York on a busy day and get away with it, I think he said.
Another question I have is how did the actions of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu play into the U.S. presidential election. How did Netanyahu hold President Joe Biden over a barrel the past year? Biden was pleading for a cease fire and Netanyahu kept up his war that resulted in a very inordinate number of Palestinians being killed, many of whom were women and children. How did that play out in Michigan where Trump’s campaign was actively working to separate Arab American voters from the Democratic Party. That separation may have made the difference for Trump in Michigan. It’s not like Trump — who moved the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem — is going to do anything for Arab Americans. Trump and his son-in-law Jared Kushner are very tight with Netanyahu.
I have other questions to raise, but they will wait for another column.